After the Holiday Table and Everyday Table reports, we turned to the party: 1980s baby showers, 1960s ladies’ luncheons, 1970s New Year’s Eve parties, a 1960s supper club, the 1970s kids’ table and how you set the table. Piaci Pizza readers cast 3,965 votes on 260 photos, plus 1,891 answers to our hosting polls.
Please note that some of the images in this article were created with the assistance of AI.
The short version: readers are fond of the retro party table (71% of all votes were hearts), with two big exceptions.
Gelatin molds lost
The 15 photos of molded gelatin and aspic dishes drew 34% hearts; the other photos in the same articles drew 73%. The two least-loved photos with 20+ votes were savoury molds, and 5 of the 15 least-loved photos were molds: “Tuna Salad Suspended in a Gelatin Ring” (3%), “Savory Tomato Aspic Studded With Celery” (4%), “Lime Gelatin Mold With Cottage Cheese Suspended…” (29%), “Perfection Salad Suspended in Gelatin” (33%) and “Crown Jewel Gelatin Suspended in Whipped Topping” (35%).
The 1980s baby shower was the one menu readers rejected
40 Things People Served at Baby Showers in the 1980s That Would Be Rejected Today drew 48%, the only article below 50%. Readers kept “Watergate Salad Glowing Pistachio Green” (96%), “Green Sherbet-and-Ginger-Ale Punch” (92%) and “Plastic-Doll Cake with a Frosting Skirt” (92%), and turned down “Tuna Salad Suspended in a Gelatin Ring” (3%), “Savory Tomato Aspic Studded With Celery” (4%) and “Canned Vienna Sausages Served with Toothpicks” (9%).
Salads split readers

Party salads drew 52%, the lowest course, and they trailed within their own articles too. Side dishes (83%) and main courses (82%) scored highest.
The 1970s beat the 1950s and 1960s

Photos that read as the 1970s drew 73% and timeless ones 83%; 1960s photos drew 66% and 1950s-or-earlier ones 61%. Many of the 1970s photos are from the kids’ table, a friendly article; compared with each article’s own average, the gap is smaller, but 1970s and timeless photos stay above average and older ones below it. In our polls, 49% said the best kind of get-together is appetizers only, and 55% cook everything themselves when they host.
The least loved

The photos readers loved most
Stuffed Celery Sticks Filled Edge to Edge
Potato Chips With the Onion Soup Mix Dip Everyone Pretended Was a…
Sherbet Punch Fizzing in the Cut-Glass Bowl
Watergate Salad Glowing Pistachio Green
Hot Chicken Salad Casserole, Topped With Crushed Potato Chips
Bowl of Mixed Nuts with a Metal Nutcracker
And the ones they rejected
Tuna Salad Suspended in a Gelatin Ring
Savory Tomato Aspic Studded With Celery
Canned Vienna Sausages Served with Toothpicks
Frozen Fruit Salad Bound With Cream Cheese and Mayo
Liverwurst-Topped Cracker Canapés
Canned Clam Dip in a Bread Bowl
The full report
The Party Food Report pools the photos by course, era, serving style, table style, linen and tableware, ranks the most- and least-loved, and adds 10 hosting polls. It includes the full dataset.
Get the full report at StatwrenHow we did this
- Readers tapped a heart or a thumbs-down under each photo in 8 of our party and entertaining articles between Oct 12, 2026 and Nov 19, 2026. One vote per reader per photo.
- Votes are anonymous: no names, emails or accounts. Readers were reacting to photos, not tasting the food.
- Percentages are the share of hearts. Traits such as course and era the photo reads as were read from each photo; article groupings are ours.
- More on how we collect reader data: How our reader data works.
