Best Store Bought Alfredo Sauce Review – 2020

What Marinara is to Pizzas, Alfredo is to Pasta! Besides, there’s so much more you can do with this thick, savory and creamy condiment in addition to authentic Italian style Pasta. Store-bought Alfredo sauce goes just as well with vegetable casseroles, deep dish lasagna and even some pizzas! (Looking for more on Pizzas? Checkout our list of the best store-bought pizza sauces!) In essence, there’s very little scope of going wrong with a good quality jarred Alfredo sauce, regardless of what’s cookin’.  

While it would make sense to make your own Alfredo sauce from scratch if you’d like to add your customizations; some canned Alfredo sauce brands do it for you. In addition to being convenient, the best jarred Alfredo sauce have the authentic creamy texture that gives them their unique identity in the first place. Premade Alfredo sauce can be bought as a dry powdered mix or as ready-to-serve jars. The latter is naturally more convenient but, on the downside, bottled Alfredo sauce is known to have a shorter shelf life. A powdered mix, on the contrary, is a better choice if you don’t plan on consuming the whole pack shortly after opening it!

We’ve been trying out some new Alfredo sauce brands lately in addition to our all-time favorites and feel the urge to share them with you. In this article, we’ve ranked some of the best store-bought Alfredo sauces that can you can buy online.

Our Top Picks

Rank PRODUCT NAME SCORE
1
1st Place
Bertolli Alfredo Sauce By Bertolli
4.8
Check Price
2
Best Value
Simply Organic Alfredo Sauce By Simply Organic
4.6
Check Price
3 Daiya Alfredo Style Cheeze Sauce By Daiya
4.7
Check Price
4 Rao’s Homemade Alfredo Sauce By Rao’s
4.6
Check Price
5 Knorr Classic Alfredo Sauce Mix By Knorr
4.5
Check Price

What is Alfredo Sauce?

What is Alfredo Sauce? – Typically used with pasta, Alfredo sauce is a white or cream-colored sauce primarily made from butter, cream and Parmesan cheese. Unlike red coloured, tomato-based pizza and marinara sauces, Alfredo sauces are light colored. Brands have started to add more flavors and seasonings to the authentic base to improve its versatility. Jarred Alfredo sauces are increasingly growing popular for their convenience and creative variations to suit certain styles of cooking.

The Origin – First used in Rome, Alfredo sauce has it’s roots tracing all the way back to Italy. The original Italian Alfredo sauce is believed to have no cream which makes it sticky and cheesy. Add the cream, and you have yourself the popular American version of it known by the name – fettuccine Alfredo.

Further along, we’ve listed some of the best tasting Alfredo Sauces across popular brands that we’ve come across experimenting with flavors. Have a quick glance!

Best Store Bought Alfredo Sauce

1. Bertolli Alfredo Sauce

Bertolli Alfredo Sauce

Pros

  • Thick and Creamy consistency
  • Lightly cooked; flavors remain intact till consumption
  • Loved by a huge amount of people
  • Goes well with soups and salads; can be used as a dip

Cons

  • Might turn rancid if kept unrefrigerated after opening

Whether Italian-style cooking is a staple for your household or you’ve been lately intrigued by their cuisine; in either case you’d require a supply of fresh, creamy and tangy Alfredo sauce to keep up with your cooking interests. Our top recommendation for you would be Bertolli’s Alfredo sauce with aged Parmesan; without any second thoughts! It’s been our personal favorite for years and still remains; even after trying almost every other brand out there. The bottled Alfredo is delivered fresh, flavorful and is ready-to-serve.

In addition to its traditional use with Pasta, the sauce goes really well as a salad dressing, as a dip and in soups. While you could serve the sauce right out of the bottle, heating it slightly really fires up all the flavors. All ingredients are lightly cooked; meaning the flavors stay intact while they’re heated right before consumption. They make the sauce with fresh cream, butter, aged Parmesan and garlic. The neat ingredient profile gives the sauce a really creamy consistency.

The sauce comes as a 15 oz bottle which may or may not be used at once; depending on your prep size. You’re advised to refrigerate to the Alfredo sauce once opened and finish the rest of it in a couple of weeks. The sauce may turn rancid if kept open for longer. Regardless, given its mouthwatering flavors, we highly doubt that will ever be the case. To sum up, the Bertolli Alfredo sauce with aged Parmesan, according to us, is the best tasting Alfredo sauce for anyone that’s fine with dairy.

2. Simply Organic Alfredo Sauce

Simply Organic Alfredo Sauce

Pros

  • It is certified as organic and Kosher
  • Very reasonably priced
  • Tastes Creamy

Cons

  • Requires to add milk and butter

Would you rather work with a powdered sauce mix than worry about finishing the open sauce bottle before it turns foul? We’ve got an apt pick for you! The Simply Organic sauce mix is our go-to choice for its durability and versatility in taste. Being delivered as a powdered mix in packets of 1.48 oz each, you prep the Alfredo in sizes that you can actually finish instantly. Indeed, a great option for people that would rather be using Alfredo sauce occasionally. True to the brand’s name, the mix is organic, gluten-free and kosher.

Further, preparing the sauce from the pouch gives you room for customization in terms of the richness and consistency of the sauce in accordance to your dish. To make the sauce from the dry mix, you need to add milk, butter and Parmesan cheese. We have also reviewed some of the best parmesan cheese available in the market. With total control over the quantities of each of these ingredients, you can fine tune the final flavor of the Alfredo sauce you serve on the table.

3. Daiya Alfredo Style Cheeze Sauce

Daiya Alfredo Style Cheeze Sauce

Pros

  • Is free from artificial flavors
  • User-friendly packaging
  • Refrigeration is not required

Cons

  • Garlicky taste do not mix well with other flavors

Milk, butter and Parmesan cheese being the core of all authentic store-bought Alfredo sauces, do vegans have an option where the taste can replicated without using any dairy products? Fortunately, yes! The Daiya Alfredo Style Cheese sauce is a virtuous replacement for the regular sauce for the people that choose to not consume dairy. We’ve tried the sauce once and boy, does it taste good! If not for the label, we bet you could hardly tell the difference.

The sauce comes ready-to-serve and involves no preparation at all. However, being packed in small pouches of 4.72 oz. each, you need not worry about finishing the whole thing as soon as it is opened. Just like any other ready-to-serve alfredo sauce from the list, you need to heat the contents of the pouch before serving. This ensures that all the flavors brought-up nicely right before consumption.

The sauce is creamy and has a thick consistency despite being devoid of any dairy products. The package contains three pouches, each sufficient for a couple of servings.

4. Rao’s Homemade Alfredo Sauce

Rao’s Homemade Alfredo Sauce

Pros

  • Cheesy Aroma and Flavor
  • Low carb; keto-friendly Alfredo sauce
  • Freshly delivered
  • Made with a combination of Parmesan and Romano cheese

Cons

  • Difficult to find in grocery stores.

With zero compromise on flavor, Rao’s Homemade Alfredo sauce is an excellent option for someone that’s looking to cut carbs. The sauce devoid of any additional sugar and people haven’t even been noticing it. The sauce comes ready-to-serve in a 15 oz. bottle.

However, as with other premade Alfredo sauces out there, you must refrigerate the bottle once open and finish the rest within a week’s time. Rao’s Alfredo sauce is made from a blend of Parmesan and Romano cheese with cream and butter. The authentic recipe makes for a thick, creamy sauce that’s versatile enough to get along with along thing you serve it with. In addition to the great taste, the sauce is keto-friendly.

This one is arguably the best tasting Alfredo sauce that is also light on carbs. The sauce is made from natural, fresh and quality ingredients like Enzyme Modified Egg Yolks, Black and White Pepper, Parmesan and Romano Cheese, Light Cream (Cream, Milk) and Butter. The natural ingredients bring natural aroma to the sauce along with the cheesy taste.

You can judge the the quality of the brand based on the fact, that the Rao’s Homemade Marinara Sauce ranks fairly highly in our picks for the best jarred marinara sauce.

5. Knorr Classic Alfredo Sauce Mix

Knorr Classic Alfredo Sauce Mix

Pros

  • Popular Brand
  • Creamy Cheesy flavor
  • Easy to store
  • Has a larger shelf life

Cons

  • Requires prep; isn’t ready to serve

Knorr, being an established brand in the food service industry, can be certain of their quality of ingredients and additives. The linked product here, is their 16 oz Alfredo sauce mix cannister. Being a powdered mix, the sauce doesn’t necessarily go bad like the ready-to-serve variants. Like their other line of products, Knorr is trusted and used by many professional chefs and restaurants for their Italian cuisines.

The ingredients in this sauce include buttery and creamy cheesy taste along with a little garlicky flavor. The Knorr brand is finest among all its other products. The sauce is thick and so, can be used not only in pasta, but also in pizza. If you wish to give it a fuller flavor, then you can add milk and butter to the sauce.

6. Whole Foods Market Alfredo Sauce with Roasted Garlic

Whole Foods Market Alfredo Sauce with Roasted Garlic

Pros

  • Made from natural ingredients
  • Freshly delivered
  • Enhanced flavour through natural ingredients.

Cons

  • Short shelf life; can turn foul is kept

A sauce is made with authentic Italian cheeses, real cream and a perfect blend of ingredients such as Sunflower Seed Oil that brings out smooth and balanced flavours to the dish. Along with cheese and cream, it also contains roasted garlic and black pepper to add spice in your dish.

The taste of this store-bought Whole Foods Market Alfredo Sauce is authentically Italian, and it can be a part of not only pasta but also pizza, lasagna, spaghetti and many more. Whole Foods Market Brand is a brand that strives for innovative flavours & products and sources them from artisans all over the world.

7. Stonewall Kitchen Basil Alfredo Sauce

Stonewall Kitchen Basil Alfredo Sauce

Pros

  • Carries unique basil flavor
  • Sauce is made up of fresh and quality ingredients
  • Can be a part of different dishes
  • Easy Storage

Cons

  • No Cons found

Started in 1991, the brand Stonewall Kitchen has developed it’s products in huge quantities. Along with the quantity, the quality of the products have also grown through leaps and bounds. This sauce tastes very different as compared to other brands of alfredo sauce.

If you are a person who tends to try different flavors of sauces in your food items, then this one is a definite pick. This sauce tastes so well that you will find it difficult to share. It does not require refrigeration or cooling. It can be easily stored outside. The Stonewall Kitchen’s Alfredo Sauces are a signature line of products as they are created for the farmer’s market.

8. Classico Extra Creamy Alfredo Pasta Sauce

Classico Extra Creamy Alfredo Pasta Sauce

Pros

  • Gluten-Free sauce
  • Tastes creamy
  • Enhanced flavour through natural ingredients

Cons

  • Shelf life of this sauce is low.

Another sauce brand that makes healthy yet best store alfredo sauce is Classico. It is a gluten-free store-bought alfredo sauce that helps you to make delicious meals such as Fettuccine Alfredo, Chicken Alfredo and Shrimp Pasta easily.  And, all of this with great taste. Isn’t that great?

The ingredients used in this sauce are Parmesan cheese, butter and a hint of black pepper for an authentic rich and creamy flavour. It is the best store-bought Alfredo sauce for the one’s looking for low-fat alternatives. This Classico Extra Creamy Alfredo Pasta Sauce is stored in a 15-ounce vacuum-sealed jar until ready to use.  

9. Botticelli Premium Alfredo Sauce

Botticelli Premium Alfredo Sauce

Pros

  • Immense flavour
  • Has high-quality ingredients
  • Packaging increases the shelf life of the sauce

Cons

  • No Cons found

Botticelli’s White Roman-Style Alfredo Pasta Sauce brings authentic Italian mouth-watering flavours to your favourite dishes. Each jar contains 14.5oz of flavorful alfredo pasta sauce carefully sealed and packaged to keep its freshness.

The sauce has rich, delicious and creamy flavour. The sauce is made by cultivating the finest and freshest ingredients such as Buttermilk, Grana Padano Cheese, Pecorino Romano Cheese, Corn Starch, Sunflower Seed Oil, Egg Yolk Powder, and Black Pepper to transform any of your meals into an Italian masterpiece!

It is the best jarred Alfredo sauce which is formed of transparent glass. This packaging increases the shelf life of the sauce. This sauce can be a part of your several dishes like fettuccine, lasagna, chicken, meatball, seafood and your other comfort foods!

10. Walden Farms Alfredo Sauce

Walden Farms Alfredo Sauce

Pros

  • High-quality ingredients.
  • Calorie Free, Sugar-Free, Fat-Free, Gluten-Free
  • Balanced Flavor
  • No Carbs

Cons

  • Shelf life is short
  • Difficult to find in grocery stores

Another sauce brand that makes healthy yet best store alfredo sauce is Walden Farms. It is a sugar-free, fat-free and calorie-free store-bought alfredo sauce that helps you to make delicious meals such as Fettuccine Alfredo, Chicken Alfredo and Shrimp Pasta easily. And, all of this with great taste. Isn’t that great?

The ingredients used in this Walden Farms Alfredo Pasta sauce are Parmesan cheese, Romano Cheese, Sour Cream, garlic, onion and freshly ground herbs and spices such as black pepper and parsley for an authentic rich and creamy flavour. It is the best store-bought Alfredo sauce for the one’s looking for low-fat alternatives. This Walden Farms Alfredo Pasta sauce is stored in a 12-ounce bottle.

Wrapping Up

We started with the question “what is the best store-bought Alfredo sauce?”, and we hope we could help you in choosing the right Alfredo sauce for you. Now, you can easily choose the sauce brand as per the dish and taste you would like to have at your home. Also, you can use a healthy version of store-bought pizza dough to make your pizza taste yummy-lious.

Leave a Comment