Skip to Content

Our Top Picks for Store-Bought Pizza Sauces

Our Top Picks for Store-Bought Pizza Sauces

Pizza is undoubtedly one of the most loved and cherished dishes all around the world. This Italian savory dish has come a long way with modifications and customisations, only adding to its versatility. While pizzas are served in a wide variety in terms of toppings and combinations; these alone aren’t responsible for the final taste of the pizza. The Pizza sauce used is just as important and should be considered with great care if you want to enjoy scrumptious pizzas at home.

Although, preparing a Pizza at home with homemade ingredients and sauces (such as Pizza sauce and Marinara Sauce) gives you the best experience of your pizza, but, preparing the pizza sauce by yourself every time is a difficult task and might consume a lot of your time.

In this article, We have listed some of the best pizza sauce brands that you can go for when you wish to make pizza at home. Out of a variety of pizza sauces, we have come up with these best tasting pizza sauce brands for your pleasant experience.

While purchasing a pizza sauce, do consider looking for olive oil in its list of ingredients. This is because, olive oil is lighter and healthier oil as compared to other oils like sunflower oil. Olive oil will also enhance the taste of your sauce resulting in better tasting pizzas. Also, do check for the texture of the sauce. A thick texture is preferred over thin sauces as the thin one may contain more water and might make your pizza taste soaky and not crispy.

Our Top Picks

1st Place
Don Pepino Pizza Sauce By Don Pepino
Check Price
2 Pastorelli Pizza Sauce Italian Chef By Pastorelli
Check Price
Best Value
Muir Glen Organic Pizza Sauce By Muir
Check Price
4 Chef Boyardee Pizza Sauce with Cheese By Chef Boyardee
Check Price
5 Ragu Old World Style Marinara Sauce By Ragu
Check Price
See also  Our Top Picks for Canned Enchilada Sauces

Best Store-Bought Pizza Sauces Brands

As you are ready with your selection guide, let’s check out the best pizza sauce to buy for your homemade pizza.

1. Don Pepino Pizza Sauce

First prepared in the 1950s in America, Don Pepino is still the best-tasting pizza sauce, according to a sizeable syndicate of pizza lovers. The Pizza sauce recipe has great taste, thick texture and a very affordable price. It is known for its cholesterol-free ingredients with a delightful taste. The sauce is prepared using vine-ripened tomatoes that give a fresh and tangy taste to the sauce.

Given that this sauce contains corn oil instead of olive oil, its cholesterol-free properties make it good option for health-conscious people. This family brand never fails you in terms of taste and flavors. Every pack of Don Pepino Pizza Sauce contains tomatoes, corn oil, salt, spices and garlic powder.

We say this from our personal experience, fresh basil goes extremely well with pizzas made using this sauce.

2. Pastorelli Pizza Sauce Italian Chef

A strong rival to the most tastiest pizza sauce (the homemade one) is Pastorelli Pizza Sauce. It is the best canned pizza sauce that has both; sweetish and spicy flavors. It has such a thick yet smooth texture that it spreads around the pizza dough easily and evenly.

This sauce is based on olive oil which makes it lighter and healthier. The Pastorelli Pizza Sauce’s flavor is enhanced by the cheese that is presented along with traditional, adult spiced and seasoning. 

See also  Difference between Marinara and Pizza sauce

The sauce is not only tastier, it is BPA-free, doesn’t contain any preservatives and is free from gluten or corn syrup. It is an award winning sauce with over 50 years of experience in the same field. Unlike Muir Glen Organic Pizza Sauce, Pastorelli’s Pizza Sauce can be shared by both adults as well as kids.

3. Muir Glen Organic Pizza Sauce

Like Don Pepino Pizza Sauce, this one too is prepared from vine-ripened tomatoes which makes this sauce thicker. Every pack of a Muir Glen Organic Pizza Sauce contains these rich tomatoes, 7 Italian herbs and seasoning which gives it irresistible taste and flavoring.

This sauce contains no additives like sugar which makes the sauce more spicy and thick. The brand uses organic tomatoes and natural herbs in the seasoning that makes the product of high quality and full of flavours. The sauce has a nice, bright and red coloured look that perfectly showcases organic and healthy tomatoes used in the making of the sauce. This pre-made pizza sauce is considered to be a healthy pizza sauce store-bought in the most organic form.

4. Chef Boyardee Pizza Sauce with Cheese

A blend of high-quality vine-ripened tomatoes with cheddar cheese, salt, soybean oil and natural flavourings makes the best-canned pizza sauce, Chef Boyardee’s Pizza Sauce. With no preservatives, it is a safe sauce to be used for making pizzas for kids.

It is a healthy store-bought pizza sauce with extra virgin oil and spices. The sauce itself contains enough ingredients and so, the person preparing the pizza doesn’t have to mix many ingredients and it makes the recipe simpler.

See also  25 Different Types of Pizza Sauce

The brand Chef Boyardee claims that their sauces are made of the most fresh ingredients that are harvested at the right time. This is the most healthy sauce among all the other sauces in the list.

5. Ragu Old World Style Marinara Sauce

Ragu’s Traditional Sauce is a Marinara Sauce which is different from normal pizza sauce. One major difference when we consider marinara vs pizza sauces, is that for pizza sauce, the raw tomatoes are smashed and used whereas for Marinara sauce, the tomatoes are previously cooked and are then smashed.

The Marinara sauce is quite thicker than the store-bought pizza sauces and tastes a little different even when it is prepared from the same ingredients. This sauce contains a blend of vine-ripened tomatoes, onions and extra virgin oil that gives a classic flavor to your pizza. The mixture contains no additives and it is rich in vitamin A and vitamin C. This makes this sauce more versatile in terms of taste, flavors and kids-friendliness.

Ragu’s Old World Style Marinara Sauce is orange-red colored and has a bit of sweet flavor in it along with the spiciness. It adds best flavors to all kinds of pizza toppings like corn, capsicum, pineapple, mushrooms and many more.

6. Botticelli Premium Italian Pizza Sauce

Prepared with a blend of freshly harvested Italian tomatoes, Botticelli’s extra virgin olive oil, sea salt, carrots, onions, and a touch of garlic & oregano, the Botticelli’s Premium Pizza Sauce is a thick and flavorful organic product. It is considered as one of the best organic pizza sauce brands because of its ingredients.

See also  Our Fave Store-Bought Alfredo Sauces (Top Picks)

Along with the above ingredients, this sauce comes from carotenoids that are responsible for its intense colour. Botticelli Premium Pizza Sauce contains It is one of the healthiest sauces as it contains fibres and antioxidant vitamins like Vitamin A and Vitamin C. This sauce can be used for the preparation of both pizzas as well as pasta.

The pizza sauce brand claims to have cooked and packed the sauce within hours of harvest to maintain the essence of organic ingredients and nutrients present in it.

7. Rao’s Homemade All Natural Pizza Sauce

Are you considering eating a healthy pizza? You can have this all-natural pizza sauce to help you out with that. The Rao’s Homemade All Natural store-bought Pizza Sauce includes Italian Whole Peeled Tomatoes, Italian Cherry tomatoes, olive oil, fresh vegetables like carrots and onions, salt, garlic and basil that adds to a healthy and a flavourful delight.

This sauce is of premium quality with rich ingredients making the sauce naturally tasty and sweet. The texture of the sauce is thick and spreads easily on the dough. Also, this sauce can be used in different recipes like pasta, lasagna, spaghetti and many more. This sauce is a great source of vitamin A and Vitamin C.

It is a gluten-free recipe that tastes delicious with all pizza topping and so, is one of the best sauces for homemade pizza.

8. Mutti Flavoured Pizza Sauce

Mutti Flavoured Pizza Sauce is prepared using vine-ripened tomatoes, salt, basil, oregano, onion and natural flavouring. It is made with the number one brand of tomatoes in Italy. The tomatoes used in this sauce are freshly ripped rich ones which provide fresh flavour and hence, the sauce has a vibrant red colour.

See also  Can You Use Tomato Puree for Pizza Sauce?

Mutti Flavoured Pizza Sauce is prepared using vine-ripened tomatoes, salt, basil, oregano, onion and natural flavouring. It is made with the number one brand of tomatoes in Italy. The tomatoes used in this sauce are freshly ripped rich ones which provide fresh flavour and hence, the sauce has a vibrant red colour. This sauce can be used in pizza, pasta and can be used as a dip for several dishes.

The sauce doesn’t include any preservatives and additives and is non-GMO and non-BPA.

9. Prego Pizza Sauce

Prego Traditional Pizza Sauce is another Marinara Sauce which is a go-to sauce for the ones who consider having sweeter taste in their pizza. Best for the kids, this sauce can also be used in preparing pasta.

The Prego Pizza sauce is quite thin in texture but, you can use it by adding some amount of tomato paste in it. It works great with cheese as the topping. We have also reviewed some of the best parmesan cheese available in the market.

This sauce contains fresh tomatoes with canola oil, salt, sugar, garlic and some spices that adds taste to the sauce. If you wish to reduce the sweetness, you can add some seasoning and black pepper to the sauce.

10. Mutti Pizza Sauce with Basil & Oregano

The Mutti Pizza Sauce is made with sun-ripened 100% Italian tomatoes, aromatic basil and oregano. The tomatoes used in this sauce are freshly ripped rich ones which provide fresh flavour and hence, the sauce has a vibrant red colour.

See also  Pizza Sauce vs. Marinara - Differences? Similarities?

This sauce is orange-red in colour and so looks less appealing, but it tastes well when added to the pizza. It is considered as the best pizza sauce as it has all-natural ingredients and doesn’t contain any preservatives and is non-GMO.

The delicious ready-to-use sauce can not only be used in Pizza, but also in preparation of flatbreads.

With 100% Italian tomatoes, this sauce is prepared in sunny skies of the Emilia-Romagna region which is considered as the food valley of Italy.

Buying Guide for Pizza Sauce

choosing the best tasting pizza sauce

As I said earlier, homemade pizza sauce tastes the best, but it consumes a lot of time and we can save that by purchasing a canned or jarred store-bought pizza sauce. While choosing a pizza sauce for your household, you need to consider the following factors to find the best pizza sauce for your homemade pizza. These factors are:

1. Choose Between a Jar or a Can

Pizza Sauce

Pizza Sauces are available in both jars and cans. There are several cans that contain BPA and it is better to avoid having BPA (bisphenol A) in your food products. This is because it causes damage to your body and skin. When you select a product check whether it contains BPA or is it BPA-Free.

2. Texture of the Sauce

The texture of the sauce must be thick (preferably marinara sauce instead of regular pizza sauce), by which, you avoid the pizza dough getting soggy. If the sauce has a watery texture, then the dough gets soggy and eventually, the pizza doesn’t get properly cooked and so, will not have a good taste. Also, you must consider not having chunks of tomato or other vegetables in the sauce. The sauce must have a plain thick texture which will provide the best-tasting pizza instead of the one with the chunks.

See also  Can You Use Passata As Pizza Sauce?

Also Read: Best Store Bought Marinara Sauce

3. Consider Your Pizza Preferences

Sicilian Pizza

Determine the type of pizza you are wishing to prepare at home. A Chicago style pizza, which is a deep dish, the New York Style pizza which is the thin crust one or the Sicilian Pizza. You can review our article to know the detailed information about Sicilian Style Pizza. As per the style of your pizza and its toppings, you must choose the pizza sauce. Also, if you wish to have an authentic pizza taste, then go for a spicy tasting pizza sauce along with a portable wood-fired oven like Forno Bello Pizza Oven.

If you are confused on the type of pizza you want and are searching for recipes, you can look at our Brussels Sprout, Cauliflower Pizza, Meyer Lemon And Butternut Squash pizza recipes.

4. Sauce’s Kids-Friendliness

Some sauces are quite spicy and might not be liked by kids. They generally prefer having mild spicy and little sweet flavored pizzas. It is preferred to check the sauce’s spiciness if you are going to have kids eating the pizza.

5. Sauce’s Veggie Content

Pizza Sauce

Some pizza sauces brands include vegetables in their sauces. This makes your pizza more healthy. This also makes kids eat vegetables without them noticing it. Although Pizza being a not so healthy dish, the vegetables in the sauce and vegetables in the toppings make it less unhealthy yet tasty. Also, some vegetables like basil add aromatic and flavory taste to your pizza.

6. Sugar Content

While you buy pizza sauce, consider checking the sugar content in it. Some canned pizza sauce brand’s sauces contain high amounts of sugar which may cause damage to your body. Also, most people do not wish to have sugar in their pizzas, so it is better to check for it beforehand. If you wish to have a combination of creamy and cheesy flavour on your pizza, you can try out one of these Alfredo sauces.

See also  Can You Make Pizza Without Sauce?

Wrapping Up

With changing times, preparing meals have become simpler. But, preparing a pizza has always been a task as there are so many things you need to consider while preparing it. With the above guide on the best store-bought pizza sauce, you can choose the best tasting pizza sauce by which your pizza making process gets simpler. Also, you can use a healthy version of store-bought pizza dough to make your pizza taste yummy-lious.


u003cstrongu003e1. What Kind Of Sauce Goes On Pizza?u003c/strongu003e

There are many different kinds of sauces that you can use on a pizza; most of the sauces used have tomato ketchup as their main ingredient. You can use Peppery Red Sauce, Barbecue Sauce, Creamy Alfredo Sauce, and many other sauces that are available in the market.

u003cstrongu003e2. Difference Between Pizza Sauce And Tomato Sauce?u003c/strongu003e

There are a few differences between tomato sauce and pizza sauce, with the primary difference being how the sauces are made. Tomato sauce is made from tomatoes (Obviously) and a few herbs and spices. Pizza sauce may or may not include tomato as an ingredient and can have cream or pesto as their primary ingredient.u003cbru003eu003cbru003eThe next difference is the usability of the sauces. Tomato sauce can be used with meat, poultry, vegetable, pizza, and pasta. In other words, the tomato sauce is very versatile. On the other hand, pizza sauce can only be used on pizza and can taste weird on other dishes.

u003cstrongu003e4. What Is The Best Pizza Sauce?u003c/strongu003e

We have listed a lot of brands in our article; each brand will have a unique taste in its sauce, and every person has a preference; this is the reason why we won’t specify and a single brand, you will just have to try and various brands and pick your favorite. Let us know in the comments section below which your favorite pizza sauce is and why you prefer that sauce.

u003cstrongu003e5. Can You Use Pasta Sauce As Pizza Sauce?u003c/strongu003e

Yes, pasta sauce can be used in pizza, but to state the obvious, the taste of the pizza will change from what you are usually used to. The main difference between the two sauces is that pizza sauce is uncooked and cooks while the pizza is being made while the pasta sauce is cooked.