Best Pizza Stone Reviews – Buying Guide

There are a lot of things that you as a pizza lover would want in your pizza, and one of that tops on the list will be the crispy crust that will help you in enjoying your pizza more. There are a lot of factors that are roped into making the best crispy crust pizzas and using a pizza stone will definitely help you get that perfect crisp. The pizza stone is something that a lot of people miss out on, and that is the number one reason as to why they end up with soggy crust pizzas. 

You can keep your pizza on the base of the stone and toss it into the pizza oven. When the pizza oven heats up, the stone will also heat up accordingly, and when there is better heat, your crust base will also get heated leaving a perfectly crisp crust on your pizza that you can enjoy. Some Pizza ovens like Ooni Koda Pizza oven and Uuni 3 Pizza Oven comes with a stone with it, they might need a replacement with a better pizza oven stones like the ones mentioned below.

These pizza stones can tolerate high heating temperatures, and that is the number one reason as to why they are considered by many of the pizza chains to make their crust crispy and tasty. This article will give you a better look at the drastic details that you would need to consider before you get yourself a Pizza stone.

Best Pizza Stones In 2020 

Rank PRODUCT NAME SCORE
1
1st Place
Unicook Pizza Stone By Unicook
4.7
View Product
2
Best Value
Cast Elegance Pizza Stone By Cast Elegance
4.5
View Product
3 Love This Kitchen Pizza Stone By Love This Kitchen
4.6
View Product
4 Culinary Couture Pizza Stone By Culinary Couture
4.6
View Product
5 Emile Henry Pizza Stone By Emiley Henry
4.4
View Product
6 . Old Stone Pizza Stone By Honey Can Do
4.6
View Product
7 Pizzacraft PC9899 By Pizzacraft
4.5
View Product
8 Heritage Black Ceramic Pizza Stone By Heritage
4.4
View Product
9 Baking Steel – The Original Ultra Conductive Pizza Stone By Baking Steel
4.5
View Product

1. Unicook Pizza Stone

Unicook Pizza Stone

Pros

  • Elegant design with proper heating elements
  • Easy to store and maintain
  • No seasoning required 

Cons

  • Can crack if rough handled or dropped. 

The Unicook pizza stone is probably the best pizza stone available if you are looking forward to pizza stones that can fit into larger ovens. The whole design of the stone is designed in such a way that the stone is capable of withstanding temperatures of 1450℉ which is pretty much the optimum temperature to consider when cooking pizzas on stone. So, you can also use this pizza stone for your Forno Commercial pizza oven or any other commercial pizza oven. The unicook pizza stone is also designed in such a way that the stone can last longer and have a much better life. 

The pizza stone is also made up of heating elements to make sure that your oven does not take up much time to heat the stone. The stone is around 6.6 Lbs which is pretty average for a pizza stone, and this will also help you in storing and maintaining the pizza stone more effectively. The heating elements in the stone will make sure that all the unnecessary moisture is sucked out of the pizza base leaving your crust crispy.

2. Cast Elegance Pizza Stone 

Cast Elegance Pizza Stone

Pros

  • Better design of the stone. 
  • Heating elements of the stone are properly integrated.
  • There are options to choose from.
  • Additional elements like scrapper and recipe book.

Cons

  • Needs some proper seasoning to cook good pizzas. 

The cast elegance pizza stone is a stone that can not only used in a pizza oven but also can be used on a grill. A lot of things that have gone into the making of this stone and the thermite that is used, the thermite is intelligently designed in the cast elegance pizza stone to make sure that your pizza crust gets cooked thoroughly. The thermite is made with the best heating elements to make sure that the heat is thoroughly distributed. The stone also comes with the proper elements to protect the base of the pizza from the intense heat of the pizza. 

The cast elegance pizza stone comes with all the standard security requirements that are liable in the US to make sure that there are no hazards with using the pizza stone. There are two types of pizza stones; one is the 16” and the 14” pizza stones. This also comes with a scrapper and a recipe book as a part of the marketing of the product. 

3. Love This Kitchen Pizza Stone 

Love This kitchen - best pizza Stone

Pros

  • Proper design
  • Comes with a pizza peel 
  • It is made with a ceramic compound that heats faster.

Cons

  • Quality of the stone needs to be improved. 

The pizza stone comes with all the bells and whistles to make sure that your pizza cooking requirements complete. The pizza stone that is included in the kit is made up of ceramic components to make sure that the heat is evenly distributed and to make sure that there is less amount of time needed to heat up the stone. The ceramic is made up of all the safety elements that are approved by the FDA to make sure that you are not left with any kind of smells when the stone is heated to higher temperatures.  Hence, you can use this pizza stone for your Roccbox or Uuni pro pizza oven.

Now the ceramic stone is made up of such elements to make sure that they are compatible with both ovens and grills. This will make sure that these are the perfect kits to make pizzas outdoors. They also come with one of the standard pizza peels to make sure that you don’t have to make an extra investment for the same. If you are looking for more options for buying pizza peels, you can review our page for the best pizza peels available in the market. Overall, the whole pizza kit is a perfect steal for anyone who is on a budget.

4. Culinary Couture Pizza Stone (Grill and Oven)

Culinary Couture Pizza Stone (Grill and Oven)

Pros

  • Standard elements
  • Portable weight and easy to clean 
  • Increased durability

Cons

  • Needs improvement in the basis of the overall design.

If you are looking forward to making Italian style pizzas with the classic Italian crust, the Culinary Couture is the best choice for you. The pizza stone is made up of superior cordierite material to give the perfect cook with every pizza that you make. There are also certain elements that are integrated into the cordierite material to make sure that they get heated faster and more durable than the regular materials that are available in the market.

There also other aspects of the pizza stone that you can consider concerning the shape and size, which is round one and the length comes around 15” and 3/4″ Thick which is suitable for baking pizzas. The layer of the superior cordierite material is also made up of glossy materials to make sure that your pizzas don’t get stuck to the stone after it is done cooking. One of the best precautionary measures that you can use with a pizza stone is that you can use a damp cloth to wipe the whole thing down to prevent it from cracking.  This sturdy Culinary Couture pizza stone allows baking up to a whopping 1000 °F.

5. Emile Henry Pizza Stone 

Emile Henry Pizza Stone  - granite pizza stone

Pros

  • Dual-purpose design
  • Granite material 
  • Ten-year warranty
  • Dishwasher safe. 

Cons

  • Higher price point

The Emile Henry pizza stone is a culmination of granite and steel surroundings to make sure that the crust of your pizzas is cooked perfectly and crispy. The pizza stone has the advantage of having granite which makes it more durable and stronger compared to other pizza stones that are available in the American market. The best highlights of the pizza stone are that it is adaptable to a grill as well as an oven that makes it highly usable. For your Bakerstone pizza oven, this accessory suits well.

There are also certain things like the whole of the design that makes it the perfect dish that can be used in the dishwasher as well. The pizza stone also comes with a ten-year warranty so that you don’t have to worry about replacing the stone for a very long time. Granite is very strong, and that means that you don’t have to worry about the stone cracking under heat. 

6. Old Stone Pizza Stone

Old-Stone Pizza Oven

Pros

  • Durable and long-lasting design.
  • Easy maintenance.
  • Can withstand heat up to 2000℉ inside the oven. 

Cons

  • A funny smell detected by many users.

Now when it comes to selecting a stone to cook your pizza, you will have to consider a lot of things, and one of the most significant concern is the size. There are a lot of pizza stone sizes that you can consider while cooking your pizza. The Old stone pizza stone is 16” which is pretty much the standard size of a pizza that you will make at home, and this can fit into pizza ovens and conventional ovens as well. The core of this pizza stone is engineered with high-quality heating elements to make sure that your crust is perfectly cooked throughout without leaving behind a soggy crust.

The materials used in the pizza stone are bonded with each other to make sure that they don’t crack, and they are built to last at high temperatures. The overall design is also perfect for any kind of oven that you might have in your home. This makes it one of the best pizza stone for oven. 

7. Pizzacraft PC9898

Pizzacraft's - Best Pizza Stone

Pros

  • Can cook different types of bread apart from the pizza base. 
  • No seasoning required.
  • It has been designed perfectly to cook evenly.

Cons

  • Slightly bigger and not optimum for smaller ovens.

The Pizzacraft PC9898 is a different type of pizza stone that when compared to other pizza stones that are present in the market. This pizza stone is made up of ThermaBond materials that allow the stone to withstand high temperatures, and this means that over a period of time, all the elements in the stone will get heated perfectly to make sure that your pizza crust gets cooked perfectly.

The pizza stone is made in a rectangular shape to aid the cooking of pizzas in brick-fired pizza ovens. So, if you have an outdoor fireplace oven at home, you can definitely go for this pizza stone. The material that is inside these stones is made of thermal shock materials that will get you long-life with the product. The best part is that you don’t have to season the stone before you begin with the cooking process as most of the stones would need that. There are a lot of different sizes that these pizza crafts come with, and most of the sizes that they offer do not become compatible with other ovens. 

8. Heritage Black Ceramic Pizza Stone 

Heritage-Black-Ceramic-Pizza-Stone

Pros

  • Durable design.
  • Easy to clean and maintain 
  • Heats up to 2 times faster than other stones. 

Cons

  • Cannot take more heat than 1000℉

This is probably one of the best pizza stones that you can come across, especially with the delicate engineering. The proper structure of the pizza stone ensures that the pizza is cooked as soon as possible. There are also various features like the materials that are used in these stones are capable of withstanding high heat temperatures, making them one of the best pizza stones that you can get your hands on. You can use this pizza stone in your wood-fired pizza oven.

There are also other features like the coating on these stones that will make sure that they will have an appealing look every single time and you will not have to worry about using rigorous cleaning methods to clean the surface. The stones also come in a very good design to make sure that they fit into any type of ovens to cook the pizza. The engineers have also made sure that you are not left with a smell once the stone heats up. Most of the pizza stones that are available in the market tend to receive this complaint. 

9. Baking Steel – The Original Ultra Conductive Pizza Stone 

Baking Steel - The Original Ultra Conductive Pizza Stone

Pros

  • Multi-purpose usage
  • Small and compact
  • Easy to clean and maintain

Cons

  • Cannot be used for large pizzas

The baking steel is a type of an alternate for the pizza stone, and the whole base is made up of steel which is pretty stronger and lighter than the pizza stone. The materials that the baking steel is made up of is ultra-conductive steel to make sure that the heat is properly distributed evenly. They are also making sure that the baking steel can also be used for other purposes. The steel can also be placed on the countertop gas to heat and cook grilled recipes as well.

Well, apart from heating, it can also be used as a heating plate to make sure that you can store raw meat and other cold materials over the baking steel. So if you are looking forward to making a multi-purpose investment, this is the best deal you can get your hands on. There are also a lot of other things like the materials that are used in the baking steel that makes it more definite in shape and size.  

Pizza Stone Vs Steel 

Pizza Stone Vs Steel

There are a lot of different types of pizza stones and steels that are available to make sure that you get the perfect crisp for the crust of your pizza. There are a lot of material characteristics that you would need to consider before you choose between a pizza stone and steel. 

If you are looking for a tool with less weight, the best choice would be to go with the pizza steel to make sure that you can lift it and place it somewhere nice and secure without the help of anyone as it is very rare that you are going to use a pizza stone or steel. 

If you are looking for a tool that is easy to clean, then the best choice would be to go with pizza steel as most of the pizza steel that is available in the market are dishwasher safe. There are also pizza stones that are dishwasher friendly, but the best would be not to use such stones inside your dishwasher. The best option will always be to opt for a steel component if you want to get it cleaned easily. 

If you are a person who just wants the perfectly cooked pizza crust and is willing to take the gamble of washing the stones and storing them, then the pizza stones are the ideal choice as most of the pizza stones are excellent heat conductors that will help you bake the perfect pizzas. 

So, if it comes down to pizza steel vs stone, it all depends on your requirements and each tool has its flaws and perfections. If you prefer crispy pizzas over the ease of cleaning, then it would be wise to go with pizza stones, but if you are looking for an all-in-one kit, the pizza steel is the best choice.

How To Choose A Pizza Stone?

How To Choose A Pizza Stone?

1. Size and Shape 

This definitely goes a long way in choosing the perfect stone as most of the pizza stones that are available come in various shapes and sizes. If you are looking to get a pizza stone only for pizza making, then go for the stones that are circular. But if you are looking for a pizza stone that has a different application, then it would be optimum to go with the pizza stone that is square-shaped and rectangle-shaped. There are a lot of different sizes that you can select from concerning the size as well. 

2. Thickness

The thickness of the stone always plays a role in the life of the stone. If you are looking forward to a stone that needs to heat up quickly, then a slightly thinner stone would be the optimal choice for you. But the thicker you go with the stone, the harder it would become for you to lift it around, so keep that in consideration as well. 

3. Surface Texture 

This is a very little detail that most of them miss out on, and this is one of the fundamental characteristics of a pizza stone that will decide whether the crust of the pizza is cooked perfectly. The surface texture can have some holes to make sure that there is even ventilation of the hot air to cook the dough thoroughly. Most of the pizza stones don’t come with the proper surface texture, and it is essential to have the surface texture to get the best crust from a better crust for your pizza.

Conclusion 

All the pizza stones that are mentioned in the article are extensively tested to make sure that they help you in making the perfect pizzas with crispy crusts to make your game night and movie nights perfect. When it comes to choosing between a pizza stone and pizza steel, it all boils down to the requirements that you would need with the same to get the job done. If you’re trying to build up your own pizza set-up and are fairly new at it, you could also use other accessories like a pizza scissor. Anyway, before you make the purchase, make sure to consider these points, and that will surely help you in purchasing the best pizza stone.

Leave a Comment