deep dish pizza pan

Deep Dish Pizza Pan Reviews – Buying Guide

There are a lot of things that will help you to make the best pizzas for your party, but the most important things are a fast cooking pizza oven like an outdoor fireplace oven or a commercial pizza oven and the pizza pan which you are using to cook your pizza through. Deep Dish Pizza pans are going to help you start from arranging the toppings to serving it to your guests. Now there are a lot of things that you would need to consider before buying your very own deep-dish pizza pan, and that is precisely what we will help you with.

When you buy a pizza pan, it is essential to consider the design consideration like pans with holes, Chicago deep dish pizza pan, square deep-dish pizza pan and much more that will help you in cooking the pizza crust throughout perfectly. If you are looking for a long-lasting material, cast iron would be the best choice. Also, make sure that the pans that you buy are very much convenient to clean and store as well. If you are looking forward to buying something big, the 14 inch deep dish pizza pan would be the right choice.

There are a lot of deep dish pizza pan manufacturers that are available out there in the American market. To make sure that you make the right choice, we have done a detailed in-depth review for each of the top brands that are influencing the American market when it comes to the best deep dish pizza pans.

Best Deep-Dish Pizza Pans

RankPRODUCT NAMESCORE
1
1st Place
Chicago Metallic Deep-Dish Pizza Pan By Chicago Metallic
4.7
View Product
2
Best Value
Nordic Ware Pizza Pan By Nordic Ware
4.6
View Product
3 Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet By Amazon Basics
4.5
View Product
4 Detroit Style Pizza Company Authentic Steel Pan By Detroit Style Pizza
4.1
View Product
5 Manpans USA Made Hard-Anodized By Manpans
4.6
View Product

Now there are a lot of pizza pans in the market, and we have made the list of the top 5 best deep-dish pizza pans that you can get your hands on. 

1. Chicago Metallic Deep-Dish Pizza Pan

chicago metallic Deep-Dish Pizza Pan

Pros

  • Simple design
  • Rigid build
  • Long life
  • Highly reliable

Cons

  • No customizations
  • No handles 

Specifications

  1. Product Dimensions is 14 x 14 x 1.5 inches
  2. Metallic Professional Non-Stick Deep Dish Pizza Pan
  3. Weight of this Chicago Metallic Deep-Dish Pizza Pan is 1.81 pounds
  4. Shipping Weight is 1.81 pounds

Now, this is the kind of pizza pan that is pretty basic and gets the job done. If you are looking forward to a simple design and cook the perfect pizza, this could be your choice. The Chicago Deep Dish Pizza Pans is one of the best non-stick bakeware that will help you in making the perfect Chicago style pizzas at the comfort of your home. These pizza pans are also made up of the most durable materials to help you get the best usage of the bakeware. The pizza pans are too strong and rigid to ensure that you have a long life with the pizza pan. 

When it comes to the size, the pizza pans come with the proper standard 14” size with a height of 1.5” that is pretty much acceptable for a pizza pan. With the Chicago Metallic Professional Non-Stick Deep-Dish Pizza Pan, you will be able to make the best pizzas in the world without worrying much. The product is definitely worth the price tag that you get it in the American market.

2. Nordic Ware Pizza Pan

nordic ware deep dish pizza pan

Pros

  • Pretty Basic design. 
  • 100% aluminium
  • Easy to use. 

Cons

  • Needs to cautiously used
  • No handles are present. 
  • Can be deformed easily if not handled with care.

Specifications

  1. Product Dimensions is 15 x 15 x 0.8 inches
  2. The Dimpled Bottom Allows For A Crispy Crust
  3. The Rust Proof Aluminum Provides Even Heat Distribution
  4. Weight of this Nordic Ware Pizza Pan is 1.54 pounds
  5. Shipping Weight is 2.95 pounds

Nordic ware is aiming to produce products that serve the purpose of cooking, and there is pretty much nothing else. When you consider the design of the pizza pan, the pan is not that deep when compared to the other products. The only advantage that you can get with the product is that the whole of the pan is made up of aluminium and this means that you will have to handle with care when you are cooking your pizzas because aluminium can get pretty hot. If you are going for this pizza pan, you will have to consider buying yourself a pair of oven mittens as well. 

The size of the pizza pan is the standard 15” size, and that is pretty much justifiable. The interior depth of the pan is only around 0.5” which is pretty much small when it comes to other pizza pans in the market. Now the only worry with this pan is the aluminium design which needs to be handled with care.

3. Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet

lodge pre seasoned cast iron skillet - best Deep Dish Pizza Pan

Pros

  • Multi-functional
  • Affordable price tag.
  • They are made of cast iron making them extremely durable

Cons

  • Needs safe handling
  • Little bulky when compared to other products. 

Specifications

  1. Product Dimensions is 23.1 x 16.4 x 2.7 inches
  2. Safe for All Cooking Surfaces
  3. Weight of this Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet is 10.8 pounds
  4. Shipping Weight is 29.9 pounds

Now when it comes to this product, it is a multi-functionary one, and if you are looking forward to getting the best of your investment in a pizza pan, this might be your optimal choice. This is mainly because this can not only be used to cook the pizza, but also used for other cooking processes as well. You can make a lot of dishes from pizzas to fried stuff, and all this will sit under a perfect price tag of $40, which is a pretty good investment for a multi-functional utensil.

This pan is also a very much functional and convenient one to use with the overall structural build and quality. The whole of the pan is made of a seasoned cast Iron to make sure that you have a pan that offers a long life with usability and durability. Now when it comes to safety, it is always best to use an oven mitt to take these things around as these things tend to heat up pretty fast. 

4. Detroit Style Pizza Company Authentic Steel Pan

detroit blue steel Deep Dish Pizza Pan

Pros

  • Different shape pizzas
  • Multi-functional 
  • Rigid build
  • High-quality steel 
  • Seasoned with a non-toxic coating

Cons

  • No handles 
  • Heavier design
  • Little big for small ovens.

Specifications

  1. Product Dimensions is 14 x 10 x 2.5 inches
  2. 100% All-Natural Non-toxic coating
  3. Weight of this Detroit Style Pizza Authentic Steel Pan is 1.5 pounds
  4. Shipping Weight is 1.88 pounds

This type of pizza pans is pretty much very difficult to find, and this is mainly because most of your pizzas are round in shape and this pizza is a big rectangle. This pizza pan is also deep enough to make sure that your pizza will cook through without any problem and within no time you will have perfectly cooked pizzas. 

The length of these pans is around 10”, and the breadth of the pan is about 14” which is a suitable size, and the whole of the pan is 2.5” deep that is probably the deepest pizza pan that you will ever find in the market. They are coated with a non-toxic coating that will help you remove the pizza from the pan without sticking to the bottom of the pans. 

The steel that is used in the pan is 26-gauge steel which is pretty strong steel and is proudly manufactured in the United States. Now if you are looking forward to a Detroit style pizza, this is the best option for you. You can use it for making Neapolitan-style pizzas or Sicilian Style pizzas. There are many types of pizzas available in the market. We have reviewed two of the best pizzas available in the market, i.e. Neapolitan Style Pizza and Sicilian Style Pizza. You can go through our article, to know the actual difference between Neapolitan Style Pizza and Sicilian Style Pizza.

5. Manpans USA Made Hard-Anodized

manpans - best Deep-Dish Pizza Pan

Pros

  • Highly Heat resistant
  • Good quality material
  • Suitable for small ovens
  • Perforated design element making cooking easier

Cons

  • Originally used for baking.

Specifications

  1. Product Dimensions is 12 x 12 x 2.2 inches
  2. Heat Safe to 700 Degrees F
  3. Weight of this Manpans USA Made Hard-Anodized Pan is 1.28 pounds
  4. Shipping Weight is 1.5 pounds
  5. Hard Anodized for Exceptional Durability
  6. PTFE Free, Water-Based Release Coating

This is a pan that is used for baking but can also be substituted to be used as a pizza pan as well. The materials that are used in these pans are put together strategically in such a way that; it can tolerate up to 700-degree Fahrenheit. The pan is 12’ deep that makes it the ideal pan to be used for baking, but if you are considering to cook pizzas, this will get the job done. The coating that is used in the pan’s interior is PTFE free that will make sure that all the pizzas that you make in these pans are not contaminated with toxic coatings. 

The pan is also perforated to make sure that you have an even cook with the pizzas, and within no time, you will be making delicious fresh pizzas in the comfort of your home. 

This very design aspect will also make sure that your crust is well cooked and doesn’t appear soggy and tasteless. You can use it for your Camp Chef Artisan Pizza Oven.

Finding the Best Deep Dish Pizza Pans

When it comes to finding the best deep-dish pizza pan, it is essential to make sure that you will go through the features that make a deep-dish pizza pan strong and long-lasting. 

1. Material and Features

The materials that are used in making the whole of deep-dish pizza pans are high heat resistant and are made up of rigid materials like Teflon and nylon. These materials will ensure that your pizza gets cooked properly throughout and you are not left with burnt pizzas or undercooked pizzas. 

There is nothing much that you would need to consider when it comes to features, but you must make sure that the handles that the pizza pans are made of are strongly built to last. You will also need to consider the pans structure and the overall attachments that come along with the pans to give you a good pizza cooking experience.

2. Shape and Size

best deep dish pizza pan

Pizzas are of different sizes, and this means that you must decide on the size of the pizzas you are going to cook before you even consider buying the pan. Also, make sure that the pizza pan that you purchase will go into the pizza oven that you are buying. Nobody wants a large pizza pan. 

The next thing you need to consider is the shape. Usually, the pizza pans come in circles, and that is the most optimum shape to help you store, clean and maintain the pizza pan as you can stack it up with the plates. But if you are considering different shapes, make sure that you have enough storage to store them.

3. Convenience

Chicago deep dish pizza pan

This is one of the most excellent features that the majority of you would miss out on. Convenience is something that most of us want with any part of life, and the same goes for pizza pans as well. Make sure that the pizza pans are of the optimum weight to lift around and use. Also make sure that you have enough cabinet space to store them or just buy the correct size of the pan that will help you store it in your cabinet, without jamming much of your place. So before you make the purchase, make sure to look into all these convenience features as well. When talking about convenience, Pizza Peel also plays an important role to handle pizza coming straight out of a hot wood-fired oven. You can check our in-depth guide for the best pizza peel available in the market.

Conclusion

When it comes to buying a pizza pan, always make sure that you buy one that meets your needs and the one that fits the inside of your oven. Also, make sure that the pizza pans are made of high-quality material to make sure that you will not have to think of replacement anytime soon. Many types of pizza pans are mentioned here, and most of them are multi-functional, and that means you can cook other dishes as well. 

If you are looking forward to this as an investment, going with multi-functional ones would be the right choice. Also, make sure that the pizza pans that you buy will fit into the ovens that you are using to cook the pizzas.

If you are looking forward to perfect styles of cooking, make sure to go for the Chicago pizza pan or the 14’ deep pizza pan to meet those requirements. 

 As a whole, the investment that you make with the pizza pan is more profitable if it can be used to fulfil some other application as well. In place of pans, you can also use Pizza oven stone for large ovens.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *